2.4 KiB
2.4 KiB
M03 Audit — Test Architecture
Milestone: M03
Title: Test architecture (smoke / quality / nightly)
Branch: m03-test-architecture
Audit date: 2026-03-09
Mode: DELTA AUDIT
Range: 7484170d (M02)...eee04b57 (M03)
CI Status: Green
Refactor Posture: Behavior-Preserving
Audit Verdict: 🟢 Milestone objectives met. No runtime behavior change. Proceed.
1. Executive Summary
M03 successfully introduced a structured test tier architecture without changing runtime behavior.
Wins:
- Test tiers (smoke/quality/nightly) established with path-based execution
- CI split: smoke on PR, quality on push to main, nightly scheduled
- Guardrails: repo check, base-branch check, pre-push hook template
- All 33 tests pass in smoke tier; deterministic
Risks: None identified.
Next action: Merge PR #2; proceed to M04.
2. Delta Map & Blast Radius
| Changed | Impact |
|---|---|
| test/.py → test/smoke/.py | Test discovery path; no runtime impact |
| .github/workflows/run_tests.yaml removed | CI workflow replacement |
| run_smoke_tests.yaml, run_quality_tests.yaml, run_nightly_tests.yaml added | New CI layout |
| warns_merge_master.yml removed | Obsolete for Serena (uses main) |
| pytest.ini, conftest.py | Config only; no runtime |
| prevent_upstream_push.sh | Optional dev hook |
Blast radius: CI and test layout only. No application code touched.
3. Category Scores
| Category | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Test architecture | 5 | Clear tiers, path-based, markers |
| CI layout | 5 | Separate workflows, correct triggers |
| Guardrails | 5 | Repo, base branch, pre-push |
| Invariant compliance | 5 | No behavior change |
| Overall | 5.0 | Exemplary |
4. Invariant Compliance
| Invariant | Status |
|---|---|
| API response schemas | ✓ Unchanged |
| CLI behavior | ✓ Unchanged |
| Extension loading | ✓ Unchanged |
| Generation semantics | ✓ Unchanged |
| CI truthfulness | ✓ Smoke deterministic, quality enforces coverage |
5. Evidence
CI (Run 22834384359)
- Smoke: 33/33 pass, 2m37s
- Linter: ruff, eslint pass
Fixes applied
- base_url added to pytest.ini (pytest-base-url)
- warns_merge_master removed
6. Audit Outcome
M03 status: COMPLETE
Audit score: 5.0 / 5
Verdict: M03 closes successfully. Test architecture in place. Proceed to M04.